In july 2017, the law commissions report proposed a new amended draft called dna based technology use and regulation bill. The chances of two people having exactly the same dna. India arguments against the human dna profiling bill 2015. Unfortunately electropherogram showed high percentage of nonspecific peak making impossible dna profiling. Advantages and disadvantages of use of dna fingerprinting. Doesnt increase crimedetection when uk police created dna. Thepresent study intends to assess the advantages and disadvantages of dna fingerprinting.
According to the government, the dna technology bill aims to establish the. The dna profiling bill is back in a new avatar heres. Bill to regulate the use of deoxyribose nucleic acid analysis of human body substances profiles. Last week, the department of biotechnology dbt released the draft human dna deoxyribonucleic acid profiling bill, 2015, on its website. The bill was expected to be presented in the parliament in the monsoon session of 2015. In 2015, indian courts have extensively used forensic evidence to.
The bill will allow the government to establish a national dna data bank and a dna profiling board, and use the data for various specified forensic purposes. Therefore, an individuals dna profile created by recording the sequence of nucleotides is unique. Dna profiling can be use to resolve paternal and ancestral issues couenhoven 2015 gave a comprehensive details of the genesis of dna profiling. The bill which is also known as the dna profiling bill, tries to check use of dna technology to establish the identity of a person.
The financial memorandum to the bill estimates that there will be a oneoff cost of. The pattern of fragment distribution is then analysed. Fatoki 2016 states that dna profiling is a forensic techniques used to identify individuals by characteristics of their dna in crime cases. Human dna profiling bill of 2018 if it is enacted by the parliament of india. The bill seeks to set up two new institutions a dna profiling board and a dna data bank. The dna based technology bill, 2017 or the human dna profiling bill is a proposed legislation in india. This bill aims to create a national dna data bank which would contain dna samples of offenders, inter alia. Crime forensic science is the use of scientific knowledge in legal situations.
First report of the law commission of india, titled human dna profiling a draft bill for the use and regulation of dnabased technology. The purpose of the bill is to regulate the already in use dna. The government also said that the final bill will be presented in march 2015. Another dna testing can be allowed if the court is convinced that the earlier samples were contaminated and hence could not be relied upon. Forensic dna testing in the united states we have 200 public state and local government laboratories performing forensic dna analysis two large private companies bode cellmark and sorenson forensics and a few smaller ones perform forensic dna analysis over 15 million dna profiles in the national dna. The bill seeks to enable maintenance of records of unidentified and unclaimed dead.
Comments on indias human dna profiling bill june 2015 version. Dna profiling can be use to resolve paternal and ancestral issues couenhoven 2015 gave a comprehensive details of the genesis of dna profiling, according to him in 1984. If one counts all official and leaked versions of this controversial legislation, this. Heres how the government plans to use dna profiles. In 2007, a draft of human dna profiling bill was made public and it was followed by criticism from the opposition, ngos and activists. The july 2015 version of the bill had been criticised by the wire for arbitrarily assigning wideranging discretionary. With the central government playing fast and loose with the contours of the right to privacy in the aadhaar case, 1 alarm bells have been set off about the implications of the governments stand in the context of other laws and measures that have a bearing on the fundamental freedoms of citizens. Dna experts may be specified as government scientific experts. The indian parliament will soon discuss a bill regarding forensic dna profiling, the terms of which will affect a vast population. It is a very sensitive technique which only needs a few skin cells, a hair root or a tiny amount of blood or saliva. In 2007 a bill known as the draft dna profiling bill was piloted by the. Dna profiling bill, june 2015 27th august 2015 also available as pdf.
Prominent among these is the draft human dna profiling bill 2015 the bill. Dna fingerprinting is one such technological advancement made in criminal justice system. The bill that provides for regulation of use and application of dna technology for establishing the identity of certain categories of persons, including offenders, victims, suspects. The dna profile of each individual is highly specific.
The commission submitted its report as well as a draft bill in july 2017. Dna profiling a south african case story in 2002, dna profiling exonerated six persons accused by the community of the rape of a ninemonth old baby girl, named tshepang. Then, the government asked the department of biotechnology and centre of dna fingerprinting and diagnostics cdfd hyderabad, to update the 2007 bill. It should not pass without substantial national debate and a. Scientific ambitions behind dna profiling bill the hindu. The dna profiling bill if approved will make india the last largest countries to adopt a finger printing bill. There is, thus, need to regulate the use of human dna profiles through an act passed by the parliament only for lawful purposes of establishing. The report sets out some major concerns including the. Each sequence acts like a code that determines the characteristics of particular individual. The draft of the human dna profiling bill 2015 has been made public by the department of biotechnology dbt.
This bill was introduced on august 9, 2018 in the lok sabha by the minister for science and technology. Human dna deoxyribonucleic acid profiling bill 2015 gaurav kumawat nishank kumawat abstract human dna deoxyribonucleic acid profiling bill 2015, which seeks to create a database where the dna samples of all the offenders must be kept in order to catch the offenders by identifying the evidences with that dna. The dna based technology use and regulation bill, 2017 or the human dna profiling bill is. The draft bill was first named dna profiling bill in 2007 and then human dna profiling bill in 2015. The dna testing bill has been in the pipeline since 2003, having resurfaced in several drafts and undergone many revisions since 2007. Dna is made up of sequence of nucleotides and this sequence is different for each individual. Forensic dna profiling is of proven value in solving cases involving offences that are categorized as affecting the human body. The government now intends to bring a bill for dna profiling in the upcoming session of parliament. The 2007 draft bill was prepared by the dob along with the centre for dna fingerprinting. Dna profiling, as it is known today, evolved from two key. Dna profiling bill the dna technology use and application regulation bill 2019 recognizing the need for regulation of the use and application of deoxyribonucleic acid dna technology in the country, the dna technology use and application regulation bill 2019, has been formulated for establishing identity of missing persons, victims, offenders, under trials and unknown deceased persons. Dna profiling bill learn about human dna profiling board. Human dna profiling bill, 2015 what is dna profiling dna profiling is a technology that can be used to identify individuals. The dna profiling bill is back in a new avatar heres the lowdown.
Why human dna profiling bill can put indians in danger. The human dna profiling bill, 2015 aims to regulate the use of dna analysis of human body substances and profiles. Indias human dna profiling bill 2015 proposes to set up a national dna database of criminals that will include rapists, murderers and kidnappers. Human dna deoxyribonucleic acid profiling bill 2015. The lok sabha has passed the dna technology use and application regulation bill, 2018 that allows regulated use of dna. The objective of the dna profiling bill is to simplify criminal investigation at the outset, as there would now be a repository of dna samples of offenders. The bill gives the dna profiling board the powers to develop guidelines for. The board, with 11 members, is supposed to be the regulatory authority that will grant accreditation to dna. This is likely due to bacterial dna interfering with the multiplexpcr i guess. Discovery of dna is considered as one of the most signi. Overview and concerns regarding the indian draft dna. As stated the human dna profiling bill 2015 is to regulate the use of dna analysis of human body substances profiles and to establish the dna profiling board for laying down the standards for laboratories, collection of human body substances, custody trail from collection to reporting and also to establish a national dna. The bill creates indices for information based on dna analysis from.
India fdnapi wiki forensic genetics policy initiative. Dna profiling bill the dna technology use and application regulation bill 2019 recognizing the need for regulation of the use and application of deoxyribonucleic acid dna technology in the country, the dna technology use and application regulation bill. Government of india law commission of india report. Dna profiling is used to solve crimes and medical problems. The bill also aims to establish the dna profiling board to lay down standards for laboratories, collection of human body substances, create a custody trail from collection to reporting and to setup a national dna data bank. Human dna profiling a draft bill for the use and regulation of. Government of india law commission of india report no. Why the government wants to photograph your private parts. The dna technology use and application regulation bill, 2018. It has helped the system make remarkable progress in recent years, despite the presence of certain challenges. Srm 2372 human dna quantitation srm 2395 y chr profiling srm 2391 srm 2391a srm 2391b srm 2391c srm 2390 dna profiling 2391 series pcrbased dna profiling nist forensic srm timeline.
1563 577 273 151 1607 747 1406 159 1323 1147 644 1176 545 3 268 1046 725 1335 174 1333 1565 1553 1424 681 839 847 939 641 1399 110 172 1027 862 255 984 1359 219 540 894 283